Life After Lockdown
It’s probably true when they say life will never be the same again. However we don’t know. And that was the general consensus at last nights “Life after Lockdown” online bonanza hosted by the main man Prof Tony Kochhar, where a whole host of field leaders got together to discuss where we are, where we are going and what we can we do to maybe reduce the impact a bit.
“Focus on what we can control” was the message delivered by Mike Reinold and one I wholly agree with. Right now it is not a lot, but the worst thing we can do is try and micro manage certain aspects of life like the news. I see it everyday where people are glued to the numbers of deaths, positive cases etc etc, when although this is a very tragic and dangerous situation for all of us these numbers depend on so much; how deaths are coded, when they were reported, how many tests are carried out, right down to a simple number such as how many in the population, so although important to have an idea of the worldly goings on for safety, try to spend some time away from it as well, or it will eat away at you.
What do we mean by control what you can control. Well we are a group of medical, health, fitness and performance specialist so this involves a person’s or athlete’s well being and training. We have no data to tell us what to do during and after a pandemic to best prepare for a return to sport or a return to life. However, a few of the speakers discussed the Myer et al paper from 2011 after the NFL lockout where disputes over contracts led to an imposed work stoppage where players were not allowed access to facilities, or communicate with the medical team, strength and conditioning coaches or any coach.
Normally in an NFL season training camps, mini camps and organised team sessions start to begin around May and build towards a full start of pre season in July with the season started mid way through September. With the lockout, activity was restricted to a pre season start in August, with the season starting mid September.
Some historic data reported by Myer et al showed that between 1980-2001 there were approximately 4 achilles tendon ruptures a year; another study (including pre season and in season) showed that between 1997 and 2001 there were 5 per year; and more recently the NFL’s injury and safety committee average 8 achilles tears in a full season.
Following the lockout there were 12 ruptures in 1 month….10 over the first 12 days.
To put an achilles tear in context, 1/3 of of players who sustain an achilles tear never play again, the remaining 2/3 of players require approximately 11 months rehabilitation to return to play with 50% not reaching the same level (Parekh et al, 2009)
This sort of comparison will be essential as world sport looks to return to competition. How long does the premier league need to get the players back on the pitch safely, NBA to the court? F1 drivers to circuit?
How long do we need? This is a question very dependent on where the athlete(s) were currently in their training or season. Eric Cressey suggested his baseball players need 3-4 weeks to prepare; they were in their pre-season and could maintain there build. Football on the other hand is halfway through a season, approaching the business end which becomes more tricky and Ben Ashworth of Sparta Prague suggested 6 weeks was a good time period to be able to have another “pre season”. Typically more injuries are seen early in the season so getting this physical preparedness right is vital. For us in F1, as I discussed in a previous blog, we were halted right at the start of the season so taking a week off to recover mentally and then picking up pre-season again was relatively straight forward from a physical perspective, however the practice in the car that will have been lost and the effect on the body that has which is hard to replicate in training will be tough…it is doubtful we will get this practice?
These thoughts were echoed by our S&C specialists with Claire Minshull, William Wayland, Alex Krawzewski and Lauran Hyser all discussing a preparatory phase prior to returning to sport (this is clearly needed given the NFL study) and utilising a minimum effective dose on return to the gym. Lauren Hyser from Eleiko used a nice system which utilised Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) for exercise and her advice was to limit RPE to 3-6 on a return to weightlifting and to track daily feeling scores of mood, physical condition, sleep and nutrition to guide whether to train and how to train, something we use a lot daily in our daily tracking. William and Alex went through a guide of low risk high reward programming which is good way of looking at it and involved aerobic based sets i.e. 1:1 work rest sets, utilising isometrics to prepare the body and using whole body routines rather than body part splits with reduced volume and higher frequency. Something we can do now as a lot of us will not have sufficient load therefore we can optimise our strength gains during lockdown by working to failure.
If you don’t have muscle soreness after the first week then you know you are not doing enough, but that’s fine, you can increase, at least you haven’t overdone it and tipped over the edge and left yourself injured or unable to train.
And that leads nice into the general population, what about you and me. Claire Minshull presented some cool studies, one of which was a paper that looked at 58-70 year old makes who undertook 12 weeks of resistance training and saw an increase of 36% in knee extension strength. They then undertook 12 weeks of detraining which involved no strength training for 12 weeks. They saw a 14% reduction in strength. They then retrained and it took less than 8 weeks to return to the strength they had pre detraining and at 12 weeks they had increased by another 10%. So the good news is that it is not all lost and it can be trained back relatively quickly AND this is not doing anything. Garcia-Pallares et al (2009) found that during a 5 week off season performing 1 session a week of 3 exercises (push, pull, squat) for 3×10 reduced the strength losses by a half. Advice for the current lockdown period: do something, even if it is only a little.
Just before some closing words, it is again good to echo some of these excellent speakers with most of those I have already mentioning plus Jarod Powell who delivered an excellent presentation based on well being, and that when we do start to return to what will be the new normal it is going to be a stressful time. We may not have the same internal response to an external load. There will no doubt be worries about job security and finances, the daily commute plus surrounding apprehension will be back, our time will be taken up again and that’s before we get to any fears around health therefore it is important we don’t add to these stressors with too much physical stress. As William and Alex mentioned, it is going to be important for gyms to be an outlet for stress and an “enhancer for stress resilience” and not the source of unnecessary stress.
What about Physio and the medical world? This is going to look rather different, and it will be down to practitioners and clinics to decide when it is safe to open. As a physio who straddles the border of elite athletes and the general population, what we do does not fall into an urgent category. However, if it means we take some pressure off redeployed NHS staff or help get someone back to work then that would be a real positive. But how much of that can be done remotely? Quite a lot! As Adam Meakins stressed with the words of the late and great Louis Gifford “Effective reassurance is a bloody good painkiller”. There will be some tough decisions to make and we will continue to look at all options and listen to the government advice…and will be fully PPE’d up and ready to go when the time comes. Personally I think remote appointments will be here to stay. Yes I miss those personal interactions, the body language cues and the hand on the shoulder that this is going to be ok. But the convenience and success of remote working for people have been clear and may open up many different avenues for both professionals and clients…I saw someone from Scotland today which would have never happened had it not been for remote working.
And finally what about this wretched Covid-19? A guest appearance from an ex colleague of mine Rebecca Robinson was a perfect way to finish the night the way we started….we just don’t know. There are findings of inflammation and lesions in the lungs, some cardiac involvement in the form of myocarditis, some systemic inflammation and vascular reaction to Covid-19 so we need to be careful when easing our athletes or clients back into activity post Covid-19 diagnosis / symptoms. There seems to be a period of recovery of approximately 10 days, then another 7 for back to training. I have had one of my triathletes who tested positive and has returned to training. He described the symptoms as a bad flu for 48 hours. He returned to training at 9 days, and a week later was back to 5 sessions a week but only now, 7 weeks on from the symptoms does he feel ready to complete a full week of “normal” training. His wife who had symptoms at a similar time continues to have “crackles” on the lung, shortness of breath and a cough which is slowly improving but limiting her return to running. An indication of perhaps the longer lasting implications of Covid-19 and I am sure we will be looking at these implications for many more years to come.
Thank you to everyone that contributed to a great evening and best of luck to you all!